
November 19, 2026
One strategy to get valued more for your quality as a premium manufacturer
Does it feel as if people don’t value quality products anymore? They’d rather choose a cheaper, trendier competitor. Discounting seems to be the only way to compete. But it doesn’t have to be this way. What if there is another, more influential reason why people buy?
I have a healthy obsession with watches. At least, I like to look at them when I pass by a jewellery store. Even after years of window shopping, I am shocked by the price difference between them. You can go from 50,000 € down to 100 €. How can the prices people pay be so different?
I asked a few friends which brand makes the best watches. Most of them named one brand: Rolex! They make the best watches. So, if you, as a premium manufacturer, make the best products, you should get paid many times more than your competitors, right?
But mechanical movements, like those used by the most expensive watch brands such as Rolex, are actually less accurate than battery-powered quartz movements. A great mechanical movement can be off by 30 to 60 seconds after a month. A quartz movement is off by only 1 to 2 seconds. This means those expensive watches are 5× “worse” than their cheaper counterparts. Why is no one complaining?
Does better quality mean higher prices?
This is similar to the current situation of premium manufacturers. It feels as if customers, especially the younger ones, don’t value quality anymore. You make products of higher quality, but seemingly worse competitors sell more and sometimes for higher prices than you. How do companies like Rolex do it?
They understood that great function is not the only reason why people buy. Another—and the most influential—reason is the emotional value a product creates. Simply put, how a product makes you feel influences your response more than how well it works.
This is called the theory of consumption values, and it was established in 1991 by Sheth, Newman, and Gross. In 2023, 32 years later, another group analyzed 82 studies about this theory and concluded that how a product makes you feel influences consumer behavior more than how well the product actually works.
But all values, there are five in total, matter and depend heavily on the context. This shows that function is not the only reason why people buy. For you, as a premium manufacturer, this means you can only charge premium prices if your quality is great. But if quality is your only focus, you miss out on a big part of value creation.
The problem with emotional value is that people don’t think it is real because an emotional response can’t be measured with technical units like meters or grams. Nor is there a single optimal emotional response to optimize for; there are many right answers. The good thing is that your competitors are most likely focused on function as well. While they sell based on features and numbers, you could focus on emotions.
Just being aware of the emotional value of your products can change your customers’ response. If you create the right emotions with your marketing, people almost sell themselves. They will tell everyone they bought because of quality, but you know they also did because of how you made them feel.
If you think about emotions when you design a new product, you could find new ways of creating value for your customers. You would ask questions like, “How might we make them feel most comfortable?” and not just, “How might we make the product 150 grams lighter?”
Next time you’re in a product meeting, just think: What if we focused on emotions?
Sources
Sheth, J. N., Newman, B. I., & Gross, B. L. (1991)
Why we buy what we buy: A theory of consumption values. Journal of Business Research, 22(2), 159–170. https://doi.org/10.1016/0148-2963(91)90050-8
Mason, Oduro, Umar & Zamparo (2023)
Effect of consumption values on consumer behavior: a meta-analysis. Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 41(7), 923–944. https://doi.org/10.1108/MIP-03-2023-0100
